Comments on: Searching the ideal commenting product for Plone http://archiv.webmeisterei.com/friessnegger/2009/12/03/commenting-in-plone/ Webmeisterei, Plone, Housing, Hosting, Premium, Portalentwicklung, Programmierung Fri, 11 Dec 2009 11:27:48 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.0.4 By: fRiSi http://archiv.webmeisterei.com/friessnegger/2009/12/03/commenting-in-plone/comment-page-1/#comment-8826 fRiSi Fri, 11 Dec 2009 11:27:48 +0000 http://www.webmeisterei.com/?p=456#comment-8826 thanks for your valuable feedback guys. i'll discuss the pros and cons with the customer (who already signaled a slight preference for disqus due to the twitter and facebook integration) and post the result here (expected jan 2010). @stefan: sure, however i'm not sure i'll make it to snowsprint this year :-( thanks for your valuable feedback guys.

i’ll discuss the pros and cons with the customer (who already signaled a slight preference for disqus due to the twitter and facebook integration) and post the result here (expected jan 2010).

@stefan: sure, however i’m not sure i’ll make it to snowsprint this year :-(

]]> By: Stefan Eletzhofer http://archiv.webmeisterei.com/friessnegger/2009/12/03/commenting-in-plone/comment-page-1/#comment-8640 Stefan Eletzhofer Thu, 03 Dec 2009 20:29:43 +0000 http://www.webmeisterei.com/?p=456#comment-8640 Hi, I'm in the same need for a (very) high volume plone site. I'll probably go the disqus route -- in the end I want to have all user-generated content handled and stored outside of plone (thus also eliminating the need to have ppl log into plone). I also have forums and guestbooks to migrate which I hope to do using the same service. Maybe team up on the snow sprint? I don't mind working on p.a.discussion, too :^) Cheers, Stefan. Hi,

I’m in the same need for a (very) high volume plone site. I’ll probably go the disqus route — in the end I want to have all user-generated content handled and stored outside of plone (thus also eliminating the need to have ppl log into plone). I also have forums and guestbooks to migrate which I hope to do using the same service.

Maybe team up on the snow sprint? I don’t mind working on p.a.discussion, too :^)

Cheers,
Stefan.

]]> By: Volodymyr Cherepanyak http://archiv.webmeisterei.com/friessnegger/2009/12/03/commenting-in-plone/comment-page-1/#comment-8637 Volodymyr Cherepanyak Thu, 03 Dec 2009 16:50:25 +0000 http://www.webmeisterei.com/?p=456#comment-8637 We at Quintagroup use in production q.plonecomments a lot in both Plone 2.5.x and 3.x. As soon as we will be able to introduce Plone 4 in our projects we expect to provide a way to switch to p.a.discussion. Also I hope we will find time to contribute to p.a.discussion as we will have few running instances of it. We at Quintagroup use in production q.plonecomments a lot in both Plone 2.5.x and 3.x. As soon as we will be able to introduce Plone 4 in our projects we expect to provide a way to switch to p.a.discussion. Also I hope we will find time to contribute to p.a.discussion as we will have few running instances of it.

]]> By: Martin Aspeli http://archiv.webmeisterei.com/friessnegger/2009/12/03/commenting-in-plone/comment-page-1/#comment-8630 Martin Aspeli Thu, 03 Dec 2009 11:47:03 +0000 http://www.webmeisterei.com/?p=456#comment-8630 If you are able to help contribute to its development (e.g. bugfixes, testing), then I think p.a.discussion is the way to go. It's got better architecture, and has a committed maintainer in Timo. It didn't quite make Plone 4.0, but may make 4.x and I'd expect it in 5. If you want something close to vanilla and low risk, then collective.discussionplus is probably the safest bet, in that it doesn't do much. I think it'll work with Plone 4 (the comment in the readme should really refer to Plone 5, which we called 4 at the time). Quintagroup's product has also been around a long time and so is probably also a safe bet. Martin If you are able to help contribute to its development (e.g. bugfixes, testing), then I think p.a.discussion is the way to go. It’s got better architecture, and has a committed maintainer in Timo. It didn’t quite make Plone 4.0, but may make 4.x and I’d expect it in 5.

If you want something close to vanilla and low risk, then collective.discussionplus is probably the safest bet, in that it doesn’t do much. I think it’ll work with Plone 4 (the comment in the readme should really refer to Plone 5, which we called 4 at the time).

Quintagroup’s product has also been around a long time and so is probably also a safe bet.

Martin

]]> By: Timo Stollenwerk http://archiv.webmeisterei.com/friessnegger/2009/12/03/commenting-in-plone/comment-page-1/#comment-8629 Timo Stollenwerk Thu, 03 Dec 2009 11:01:04 +0000 http://www.webmeisterei.com/?p=456#comment-8629 Hi, I'm still actively developing p.a.discussion and it has been used in production by teamrubber since its pre-alpha1 state. I think Jarn is also using it for a project. I hope to release a first beta version soon. Feel free to contact me if you have any questions. Timo Hi,

I’m still actively developing p.a.discussion and it has been used in production by teamrubber since its pre-alpha1 state. I think Jarn is also using it for a project. I hope to release a first beta version soon. Feel free to contact me if you have any questions.

Timo

]]>